Andrew Mobbs (mobbsy) wrote,
Andrew Mobbs
mobbsy

One film I saw today was Visit Palestine. It was a very interesting and powerful documentary following a peace activist, Caoimhe Butterly, her actions in Jenin and Palestinian life under Israeli occupation.

It was obviously one-sided, but at the same time came across as entirely truthful. It didn't try to examine the causes and justifications of the occupation, only the consequences to the people. We saw demolished houses, tanks patrolling streets and soldiers firing in residential areas and children throwing stones at armoured vehicles. There were interviews with families who'd had their houses demolished as collective punishment, children with bullet wounds, women whose husbands and children had been killed or arrested without charge. We didn't see groups of armed men, rockets fired into Israeli towns or any real signs of serious violent resistance. It was truth, but only part of the truth.

I imagine that would be answered by claiming it was merely countering existing media bias, where activists assert (probably with very good reason), that Western reporting of the conflict overly emphasises Israeli casualties against Palestinian.

Overall, I came away with a reinforced impression of Israeli over-reaction and inhumane oppression of the entire community, but not forgetting the circumstances that don't excuse the behaviour but may explain it. I also was impressed by the bravery of the activists, standing in front of tanks and blocking armed soldiers from shooting.

Both the film-maker, Katie Barlow, and the activist Caoimhe Butterly were in the cinema afterward for a question and answer session. That was well worth being at too. Caoimhe suggested that the solution to the situation was very simple, that Israel withdraws and all violence would stop. I'm not sure I believe that, she didn't mention the problems like water rights and settlements, let alone the hatred and distrust documented in the film we'd just seen.

Should Israel exist as an independent state?

Yes
10(90.9%)
No
1(9.1%)

Should Palestine exist as an independent state?

Yes
10(90.9%)
No
1(9.1%)

Should the boundaries be on the pre-1967 lines?

Yes
7(70.0%)
No
3(30.0%)

Is there a viable peaceful two-state solution?

Yes
7(77.8%)
No
2(22.2%)

Could this be achieved simply by Israel withdrawing entirely behind pre-1967 lines?

Yes
0(0.0%)
No
11(100.0%)
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 8 comments